Credit Card Offers
Credit Cards Card Perks™ Commentaries Financial Services Blog
Commentaries
View All Issuers
Post a Review
 

Credit Card Commentaries

 
 
 
 
post your review
 
view other cards issued

 
TD Waterhouse Free Trades Platinum Visa® Card
Issued by First USA

Total Posts: 3 Average Rating: 3.5 Category: Reward - Other
 
 
 
Showing 1 - 3 of a total of 3 Commentaries
 
1-3
 
"Hurricane Interest Rate hikes"
They increase your interest rate when you use
the card many times, even if you are not late or over limit. Increases even if you are declared a FEMA Federal Disaster Area.
 
Most attractive feature: Stock Trade Credit
Least attractive feature: Interest Rate Hikes
 
Overall:
Benefits:
Service:
 
Posted by: Bill
Date: 9/9/2005
Recommend?
This person does not recommend this card.
 
 
 
"Great for TD Waterhouse customers, but why be their customer?"
First off, I&#'ll say that the basic service on this card has been excellent. Customer service has been friendly, payments have been applied quickly, and grace period has been honored. I have not had any extreme problems that would put customer service to the test, such as fraudulent charges, however. There has never been an annual fee. I have used this card since TD Waterhouse involuntarily switched everyone from their old credit card to this one in the spring of 2001.

As far as I can tell this card is only available to customers of TD Waterhouse Securities, a discount brokerage. There are two hooks to get you into this card. The first is a 5% rebate on purchases from some Web merchants, including Amazon.com. The full list is available on TDW&#'s Web site. I am not much of a Web shopper so I never looked at the list. I do know that Amazon.com is on the list, and a few purchases from them always led to a rebate appearing on the next statement. I don&#'t know how many other cards offer this benefit. For a heavy Web shopper, this could be a very valuable benefit.

The other benefit is that for each $2,000 charged, you get a voucher with your statement that you mail in with a copy of a transaction confirmation and the commission is rebated. I got several rebates and all were handled quickly and smoothly. A basic stock transaction on the Web is $12 at TDW, so that&#'s not a great percentage return. If you use a live broker or trade bonds or options, the commissions are a lot higher, so you can get a more valuable rebate if you trade those instruments. I&#'m sure there is a maximum rebate amount but I never hit it with my small option trades. If you were in the habit of making one or two option trades a month, and you charged $3,000 a month, you could get all your commissions rebated.

For most investors seeking a true deep discounter, however, I don&#'t think TDW and this card is a very compelling combination. I traded with TDW for about 8 years, and was generally happy with them, but they have changed and I am now abandoning them. TDW seems to have decided deep discounting isn&#'t where the profits are, and they are now trying to be a clone of Schwab. I think they beat Schwab hands down, offering all of Schwab&#'s bells and whistles at a much better price, but the remaining true deep discounters are now beating TDW badly on price. The last straw for me was when TDW slapped a .5% back-end fee on every mutual fund sold within less than 90 days of purchase. As a mutual fund trader, this could have cost me hundreds of dollars a year--much more than I could save with the card. I am transferring accounts to Brown & Co., where market orders are $5 and mutual fund trades are a flat $5 with no extra back-end fee. I have had one account with Brown for a few months now and have been very pleased with the service. Their Web site is simplistic and they don&#'t give free access to S&P magazine and such, but I figure I&#'m better off saving money on commissions and fees and paying for subscriptions to magazines if I want them.

In short, the only people I would recommend TDW (and this card) to would be people who trade bonds or options on a regular and compatible schedule or people who want a clone of Schwab with dramatically better commissions.
 
Most attractive feature: Commission rebates can be a valuable benefit for TD Waterhouse customers
Least attractive feature: TD Waterhouse is no longer the best discount broker
 
Overall:
Benefits:
Service:
 
Posted by: William
Date: 4/2/2002
Recommend?
This person does recommend this card.
 
 
 
"Great way to earn free trades"
This card is better than the standard e.card platinum because of the free trades rewards. For every $2000 spent on purchases you get a certificate that you can use for a trade up to $45. This is very useful for those who frequently trade over the phone ($30 for a market order, even more for limit orders and others.) I frequently shop at amazon.com and I also have a TD waterhouse brokerage account so this is a double bonus for me. The intro APR for this card used to be 0% for 6 months but they recently changed that to 2.9% for 6 months so I was a little disappointed. I usually pay off my monthly balances unless there is a 0% interest rate, then I just pay the minumum. The standard APR on this thing is between 14.99% and 19.99%. Of course this card has all the standard features of a platinum card. You can't apply for this card on the First USA website, you have to go to the banking section of the TD waterhouse website to find this card.
 
Most attractive feature: Earn Free trades for TD Waterhouse brokerage accounts, 5% off at select online merchants
Least attractive feature: Reward points expire in a year and redeemed certificates expire in 6 months
 
Overall:
Benefits:
Service:
 
Posted by: David
Date: 9/21/2001
Recommend?
This person does recommend this card.
 
 
 
 
Showing 1 - 3 of a total of 3 Commentaries

1-3